HDR Environment map doesn't work unless I convert it to a PMREM

Questions
, , ,
1

MeshStandardMaterial doesn’t work with a HDR equirectangular environment map unless I convert it to a PMREM.

Not sure if this ever worked, but I feel like I would have noticed before if it was not possible.

Here’s a pen that demonstrates what I mean:

This fails:

const envMap = await loadEnvironment();
scene.environment = envMap;

1
1749×610 6.75 KB

This works:

const envMap = await loadEnvironment();
const envMapPMREM = createPMREM(pmremGenerator, envMap);
scene.environment = envMapPMREM;

2
2749×603 44.3 KB

Is it required to use PMREM with MeshStandardMaterial now? I know it’s required for correct results, but I’m sure it used to at least work previously.
Or perhaps I need to change some settings on the loaded texture?

2

lol @ timing

3

:sweat_smile:

Sorry, I didn’t see your post before I made mine.

Have you tested this with LDR maps or cubemaps?

4

just LDR. I think if this is unintended then it was broken for months without anyone noticing.

5

OK, well I have only tested with HDR so it’s probably all of them.

6

see Envmap + no lights = dark scene

7

Thanks. So the answer for anyone else coming here is that you cannot use equirectangular textures as environment maps with MeshStandardMaterial.

8

The terrible thing about this is that I’m actually the person who added the note to docs saying that equirectangular maps are not supported :unamused:

9

Don’t worry about it. Details like that can easily be overlooked. After all, it was easy to clarify the situation because of the docs :wink:

10

And from your commit message it was after WestLangley commented on Aug 14, 2018, so 1.5 years now, not “months”. Now how many projects I have shipped during that time not noticing it was not working because the lights were on :thinking: