Hello! As the title says I have problems bevelling with a high bevelOffset. So far it seems that this problem only occurs with shapes that contain holes. Here’s an example: https://jsfiddle.net/yxcskwdz/14/ The inner radius is 32, the outer radius is 40 and the bevelSize and bevelOffset are 3 and…

Not every bevel parameter combination makes sense with a given geometry. Do you mind sharing a screenshot of how the result should look like?

Both of the examples should result in the same geometry (if we don’t consider the depth). The first one has higher difference in the radii (40, 32). The second example has a smaller difference (37, 35) but is then expanded by the bevel (since the negative bevelOffset is not present). EDIT: Added a…

There is indeed a problem with negative bevel offset however there is already an issue at GitHub tracking it: ExtrudeGeometry produces incorrect faces with negative bevelOffset opened 05:41PM - 10 Sep 20 UTC (UTC) …

I’m afraid this issue does not have a high priority. Especially since there are workarounds.

What workarounds do you suggest? I know that in the example above the workaround is pretty simple but for more complex shapes with holes this kind of workaround is not an option.

True, the workarounds do not apply to all use cases.

ExtrudeGeometry bevel fails with high negative bevelOffset (shape with a hole)

Questions

Martinusius June 4, 2021, 4:57pm 5

Interesting. It seems that there hasn’t been any new information about the issue for almost a year. Are there any plans on resolving it?

Topic		Replies	Views
Jedi Fighter wings occur on ExtrudeGeometry when bevels are too deep . How can I tell this is happening? Questions geometry , extrude-geometry	4	651	December 2, 2019
Bevel Modifier for Three.js Questions geometry , modifier	2	3571	July 21, 2022
Extrude geometry not giving the desired result Questions geometry	0	472	February 23, 2021
Extrude Geometry extension request: different front and back bevel parameters to model gemstone cabochons Questions geometry , extrude-geometry	3	811	October 24, 2022
Extruded arc shape geometry not closing Questions geometry , extrude-geometry , shapes , path	7	180	February 22, 2025

ExtrudeGeometry bevel fails with high negative bevelOffset (shape with a hole)

Related topics